After a lifetime of study, aurora still a mystery

Coronal Mass Ejection solar Sun magnetosphere space weather
A coronal mass ejection (CME) erupting into space, travelling at speeds over 900 miles per second. CMEs which connect with Earth’s magnetosphere cause auroras to appear. / Courtesy National Aeronautics and Space Administration

Ned Rozell for UAFGI

Sometimes, after idling in the sky for hours as a greenish glow, the aurora catches fire, erupting toward the magnetic north pole in magnificent chaos that can last for three hours. “Substorms,” as space physicists call them, can happen two or three times each night.

The man who came up with that name half a century ago has, with a former student he once mentored, come up with a new theory on the location of heavenly energy for these auroras.

Syun-Ichi Akasofu first heard the word aurora from his mother, who sang it to him in a lullaby. He would not see the phenomenon until he was 28, when in the late 1950s he traveled from Japan to the Geophysical Institute at the University of Alaska Fairbanks. He has been here ever since.

Syun-Ichi Akasofu aurora research University Alaska Fairbanks
Syun-Ichi Akasofu in his office. / Photo by Ned Rozell

During much of his six decades in the far north, he has pondered the complicated mechanisms that trigger the aurora. But there was a 20-year gap in Akasofu’s academic pursuits when he served first as director of the Geophysical Institute and then the International Arctic Research Center, both at UAF. He retired from high-level administrative work in 2007, and now spends fewer hours at the office.

Now that he has free moments, Akasofu has, with some controversy, dug in to study the natural component of climate change, pointing out that the world should be getting warmer as it recovers from the Little Ice Age, which ended in the 1800s.

He has also returned to his first love, the aurora. Akasofu and the man who was his first post-doctoral student — Tony Lui of Johns Hopkins University — have come up with an idea that’s different from a foundational belief of many who study space physics. That is not unusual for the 83-year-old contrarian.

“I always become suspicious when many scientists agree on some interpretation,” Akasofu once said.

Before pondering what he believes is evidence for the new idea about substorms, here’s an oversimplified view of how one works:

Our sun, that burning ball of hydrogen gas, blasts a constant tsunami of gases over marble Earth. This solar wind flows over and behind Earth like a stream rushes around a boulder. Scientists came up with the name “magnetosphere” for the windsock-shaped flow around the planet.

Sun Earth Magnetosphere space weather Solar Wind
An artist’s rendering of solar wind coming towards the Earth and its magnetosphere. / Courtesy National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Camilla Corona SDO

In the tail of this magnetosphere, way downstream from Earth, is where aurora researchers have long theorized that solar energy is changed into substorm energy, which then explodes Earthward by the process scientists call “magnetic reconnection.”

Akasofu always thought the magnetic reconnection theory was not applicable to the aurora. Based on his study of the aurora and satellite observations, he figures that there is not enough energy in the tail.

Tony Lui, who studies at the Applied Physics Laboratory at Johns Hopkins University, recently noticed a satellite observation that supports he and Akasofu’s hunch. They think the sun’s hot breath is stretching Earth’s magnetic field lines like a kid pulling back on a slingshot. When the field lines can no longer hold the stretching, they snap back toward the planet. In the process, electrons are separated and stream into Earth’s upper atmosphere. Those electrons bang into atoms of oxygen, which explode into swirling auroral substorms.

Aurora Borealis purple red blue green Arctic
Aurora borealis showing purple / Courtesy National Aeronautics and Space Administration

Also evident to the pair is that this magical, substorm-causing process may occur about half as far from Earth than scientists have thought. This news might not change your appreciation for aquamarine lights detonating in a cold, clear sky, but a few space physicists will debate it with passion.

Having released the idea, Akasofu is content to let others bat it around. In a career entering its sixth decade in which his own theories have been both embraced and disproven, Akasofu wonders if we will ever fully understand the aurora. One of his favorite quotes regarding the mystery of it all is from Charles Hall, an arctic explorer of the 19th century, who, pondering lights in the sky, wrote in 1864: “Who but God can conceive such infinite scenes of glory?”

The Alaska Science Forum has been provided as a public service by the Geophysical Institute, University of Alaska Fairbanks, in cooperation with the UAF research community since the late 1970s. Ned Rozell is a science writer at the institute.

Posted at University of Alaska Fairbanks Geophysical Institute : Alaska Science Forum by Ned Rozell on February 28 2013


Frontier Scientists: presenting scientific discovery in the Arctic and beyond

Space Weather & your Technology, Space Weather Predictions